I installed Google OS (Chromium really) in a virtual machine to try it out. It really is as simple as advertised. Here’s everything you have to do.
The first time you use the computer
Tell the machine how to connect to the internet. It was ethernet rather than wifi. Presumably because the VM is networked to the host machine.
Username/password for google account if have one.
Image you’d like to use for identification.
Practice with your touchpad. You can see this online. It’s pretty cool in that it picks up on the fact that I have a smart touchpad. In my Safari browser on the host machine, I can drag and drop and the like. In my Chrome browser on the guest, I cannot. Both the laptop and external trackpads work fine in the Chrome browser on guest; it’s just the test page giving me problems.
Usability issue: It took me about five minutes to realize that was it. It’s a normal browser window from which yo can go to other websites.
Click time and “open date and time options” to get the control panel lite. This is where you can say you don’t want passwords saved, set up security and other preferences. You can also get here by clicking the wrench on the right side of the screen.
If you close the browser, you get the bookmarks bar. It starts with an option to take you to the webstore which offers both free and paid apps. You mean you didn’t want to play Angry Birds? The other built in option is the file manager which appears to host local and cloud storage. I was puzzled because I thought there was no local storage.
There options for the browser are easy to read.
The second login
It shows your cute icon/avatar. It took about 15 seconds to launch. I’m not sure how much of that is Chromium and how much is me launching a computer within my computer. (For the more technical folks reading this, I imagine starting a real computer is going to be about the same or a little slower.)
I’m getting tired of reading reviews that say the Chromebook is more limited than a netbook and therefore a waste of money. These reviews miss the point. Disclaimer: I haven’t touched a Chromebook – this is culled from other reviews. Who is the Chromebook for?
I can think of a few target audiences for the Chromebook:
Senior citizens who use a computer to check e-mail, view pictures of the grandkids, research vacations, maybe watch some videos on youtube and some other random surfing. People in this group do not want anything to do with taking care of their computer; they just want it to work.
Young children who are just browsing and whose parent’s want the computer locked down. (I actually think this case is marginal since children are typically going to use educational software and outgrow it quickly. I’d favor an iPad with an optional keyboard for this group.)
Teens and college students. I didn’t think of this one but if all you do is write papers, play games and surf the net, why bother worrying about a firewall/virus scan/etc. I also like that this review was written by a teen – aka someone actually in the target audience being discussed.
You notice who is not on the list: technical people, people who like to fiddle with the computer, people with “advanced” needs, etc.
Now let’s look at some reviews of the Chromebook. Nothing against the NY Times; I read that review first and got aggravated with it first. Most of the points I brought up there I saw in other reviews as well.
No Bluetooth, Ethernet jack, FireWire port or DVD drive.
Likely hasn’t even heard of the first three let alone wanting to fiddle with them. For a DVD drive, one can listen to music online and can’t install anything, so who needs a DVD drive.
If everything is online this is ok. If not, should have a different device.
Depends on the person. I can’t imagine not having a DVD drive and being able to install software in college. But then I was a geek and computer science major. If someone just wants the internet, it could be ok.
But what if you want to run real, brand-name software? Photoshop? Quicken? Skype? World of Warcraft? FileMaker or Access? How will you sync or back up your iPad, iPhone or iPod if you can’t run iTunes? What about the specialized apps that your company might require?
If you need any of these apps, you need a real computer and aren’t in the intended audience of a chromebook. And if you aren’t retired yet, your company should be providing a computer.
This is why I think young children would be better off with something else.
This would have killed it for me in college. I needed way too many apps.
But does the $499 Samsung Series 5 deliver as much performance as similarly priced netbooks?
They are framing the question wrong right in the first paragraph! It’s not a netbook. I actually didn’t take issue with the rest of the review. It was very neutral and they stated things as facts rather than “limitations” so it is up to the reader to decide if that is something he/she cares about. Nothing about target audience, but nothing against it either.
Like LaptopMag, the actual review was pretty neutral and stated facts. A negative rating without any mention of a target audience though. (and of course it is forward looking – that’s what one does entering a market)
While I can’t imagine using this as a work machine, ZDNet extensively talks about a target audience. (The reason I can’t imagine it as a work machine isn’t because I am technical. It is because I work for a bank where putting all your data in the cloud and off VPN seems insane.)
I read a number of reviews but it was basically more of the same. Has anyone seen a review that actually review about how the Chromebook would be for some target audience? Zdnet was all I could find from someone who has tried a Chromebook.
As Mark Spritzler notes “The thing with the Chromebook, is there has never been a device like this for the actual purpose that the Google Chromebook was created for.” This is precisely the problem I am seeing in the reviews. Google isn’t trying to compete with existing netbooks or even tablets. They are trying to create an “internet surfing machine” and reviewers are looking at what it can’t do rather than the benefits. Going back to our target audiences: they are all groups that will pay the same amount or even a premium for something simpler. Less complexity which means less problems which means a better experience.